Help Me !!! ICW vs JLC. Which one you prefer?

[andylliao]

Portuguese Yacht Club Chronograph vs

Master Compressor Extreme World Chronograph

Can anyone help me decide which one is better? About the movement, accuracy and the value? The advantage of IWC is the clear display case back vs JLC solid.
Thanks

[CitizenM]

Very tough call and both have world class movements. I imagine the JLC will have better value retention.

I like how the IWC looks more, but I do like some of the complications on the JLC.

Hopefully someone with more knowledge than myself can brief us on the respective qualities of each movement.

[Nishant]

Hate to say it, but IWC takes the CAKE.

[andylliao]

I have no idea to compare with this two. Both of them are same weight in the battle , I think so!

[alexoh85]

JLCs dial is too complicated for my tastes. IWC yachtclub looks super classy and it looks pretty sweet.

[lindstd]

I think JLC makes great watches with great movements however that watch is just way too busy for me. I think the IWC yacht club is absolutely stunning. It also looks great on a alligator strap. I like the black dial however I prefer the white dial on the yacht club but either way I like the that watch a million times more than the JLC. In terms of looks it is a no brainer for me.

[p_mcgee]

I prefer the JLC brand to IWC in general, but for this comparison I'd pick the portuguese chrono. There is too much going on for me on that JLC dial. I suppose if you travel alot and like to time things it could be useful, though.

[Will_f]

JLCs dial is too complicated for my tastes. IWC yachtclub looks super classy and it looks pretty sweet.

+1. Even though I really like JLCs, in this case the IWC wins on looks easily.

[wicked]

The JLC is not just a chrono, it's also a world-timer, surely it'll look busier. In terms of movement and accuracy, JLC is superior, but we are really talking abt two different watches here.

[slashd0t]

JLC has way too much going on.. If I want all that junk, I go to my mobile phone... IWC for sure..