Gonna Buy One... Help Me Decide.

[erikclabaugh]

Yep, its another one of those threads...

I have been wanting a Hamilton for quite a while. I recently received an Amazon gift card, so it looks like it is time to pull the trigger. I have narrowed it down to four choices. I took a serious look at my existing collection and realized some things. First, I have a lot of black faced watches. Not a bad thing, but, for variety, I think I would like to go with a lighter faced dial. Second, I am a graduate student (rebooting my career- I'm 38, and sold a company a few years back), so my style of dress is rather informal. Jeans, khakis, buttondowns, T-shirts- that kind of thing. So, I don't want something that is too dressy. Wrist = 7 1/4 inches.

Here are the choices, and my thoughts each:

Ventura:

Pros: Love the look. Very different than anything I have now.
Cons: 31mm case (too small?), Black dial, Too far out there for normal wear? Quartz (ho-hum)



Jazzmaster Viewmatic 40mm

Pros: Nice size, automatic
Cons: Too dressy? Somewhat boring?



Timeless Classic 42 mm

Pros: More casual look. Cool retro vibe, auto, decent size
Cons: No see through caseback, still a little bland (but might look better in person)



Cushion 44mm:

Pros: I have seen one in person and the case simply shines, auto, again, nice retro vibe
Cons: Too big?, Too dressy?



All of these watches are within about $100 bucks of each other, so pricing is not a factor.

Looking forward to the responses! Owners, if you have pictures (wrist shots would be great!), I would love to see them.

Thanks for the help guys. Can't wait to join the Hammy club!

[mjrchabot]

All of those watches are relatively dressy. What type of look are you going for?
Of the watches you mentioned, I vote for the Timeless Classic 42mm.

[LambChopFamily]

I have a Cushion and it is very elegent but with lots of presence due its size. I will go with the Cushion
if you have a large wrist if not the Timeless. The Timeless is also very classy. Either one you will be very happy Hamilton owner.

[erikclabaugh]

All of those watches are relatively dressy. What type of look are you going for?
Of the watches you mentioned, I vote for the Timeless Classic 42mm.

Hey MJR- Thanks for the response. I guess the best way to describe the look I am going for is simply "casual." Just want something that does not look out of place if I am wearing shorts or jeans. Having said that, I am beginning to lean toward the timeless.

[erikclabaugh]

I have a Cushion and it is very elegent but with lots of presence due its size. I will go with the Cushion
if you have a large wrist if not the Timeless. The Timeless is also very classy. Either one you will be very happy Hamilton owner.

Hey Lambchop- What size wrist do you have? Any pictures? Might give me a good idea of the size. I currently have a Magrette Regattare "Bronze" (Brass) that is 44mm, and I like the way that wears... but, I have found that every watch is a little different. I have worn some 42s that have appeared larger than 44 just because of the design. Anyway, I would love to see some wrist shots.

E

[LeonMan]

I like the Cushion 44mm. I have big wrists, so I tend toward the bigger cases. Aside from the size, I think the design of the case and how it meets the strap give the watch a unique style. Considering a Jazzmaster Maestro myself. Good luck.

[napel]

Yep, its another one of those threads...

I have been wanting a Hamilton for quite a while. I recently received an Amazon gift card, so it looks like it is time to pull the trigger. I have narrowed it down to four choices. I took a serious look at my existing collection and realized some things. First, I have a lot of black faced watches. Not a bad thing, but, for variety, I think I would like to go with a lighter faced dial. Second, I am a graduate student (rebooting my career- I'm 38, and sold a company a few years back), so my style of dress is rather informal. Jeans, khakis, buttondowns, T-shirts- that kind of thing. So, I don't want something that is too dressy. Wrist = 7 1/4 inches.

Here are the choices, and my thoughts each:

Ventura:

Pros: Love the look. Very different than anything I have now.
Cons: 31mm case (too small?), Black dial, Too far out there for normal wear? Quartz (ho-hum)



Jazzmaster Viewmatic 40mm

Pros: Nice size, automatic
Cons: Too dressy? Somewhat boring?



Timeless Classic 42 mm

Pros: More casual look. Cool retro vibe, auto, decent size
Cons: No see through caseback, still a little bland (but might look better in person)



Cushion 44mm:

Pros: I have seen one in person and the case simply shines, auto, again, nice retro vibe
Cons: Too big?, Too dressy?



All of these watches are within about $100 bucks of each other, so pricing is not a factor.

Looking forward to the responses! Owners, if you have pictures (wrist shots would be great!), I would love to see them.

Thanks for the help guys. Can't wait to join the Hammy club!

Try the Cushion Chrono if you think those are too dressy

[erikclabaugh]

Hmmm... Cushion chrono is sweet!

[prop]

yhm, If I were sit on your chair I would pick the Cushion Chrono.

Its still classic watch, but the chrono makes him more universal.