Well, I didn't just stop at the hands. I decided to do the case at home instead of sending it out. Dressed the case by hand with 400 grit sandpaper and water, took about an hour to get the look just right. No more scratches and the micrograining is in the sunburst pattern.
Now to find the second hand, I know I can put a SST pumpkin sweep hand in but it is not quite the same.
Before and after
Front and back
dial and movement