A short while back I posted this fortunate thrift find Rolex Precision. Watch is now at my watchmaker and I am torn as to whether to have the case polished or not. I am aware of the general consensus against polishing. Just not clear whether this applies to any and all situations. My watch maker is confident of his polishing skills, seems to know how his model should be polished and has a strong opinion that a Rolex should look better than this does and is in favor of polishing. I am intending to wear this watch at least somewhat and I would like it to look nicer. But of course do not want to lose significant value. And it's not like it's a rare or highly collectible model. So before making a final decision I was hoping for a few additional thoughts from this group whose opinions I greatly respect.