So...how do you wear your watch?
snug..not tight but definitely doesn't move around..you don't like watch flap
semi loose..moves around barely
loose..moves around lots, you can turn your watch around on your wrist.
Here's another way of looking at it: If you got a watch and the hole spacings were far apart, like a frogman strap, and you tried it on and couldn't get it adjusted to the exact way you like to wear your watch, which way would you go? What, from the above, would you pick?
This is fun...no?