I am having a heck of a time trying to decide what my next purchase is going to be. I think I have it narrowed down to a Blue Tudor Black Bay and a Omega Planet Ocean 8500 (both pre-owned). My current collection is as follows:
Rolex Sub C
Breitling Avenger Seawolf
Omega Speedmaster Pro
Omega Planet Ocean 2500
Current grails would be Rolex Exp II 42mm & GMT II BLNR (but those are little out of my price range at the moment)
I originally wanted the Black Bay on the fabric strap because I thought it would be different from my other watches. However, I know that I didn't love the snowflake hands at first sight. I think I have somewhat convinced myself to like the Black Bay . However, every time I see pictures of the new 8500 PO, I think "Now THAT is a good looking watch." I am torn, though, because I know how similar the 8500 is to the 2500, and in fact people prefer the 2500 for certain reasons. I am not interested in flipping the 2500 (for sentimental reasons), so I am stuck trying to figure out whether I should get the 8500 despite it being so similar to my current watches...
Any advice or thoughts?