I found a small consignment jewelers in my town. They has several Rolex watches. Mostly Date Justs, and also an Explorer and one gold Daytona ($24.5k). They also had a Zenith El Primero ($3.5k) and an Omega Speedmaster Automatic ($2.4k).
I was momentarily tempted by the Omega, but it wasn't a Moon Watch.
But at least now I know where to go.