OP, if your wife was also a watch enthusiast, I would definitely not gift a watch. But seeing that she’s not, and only owns 2 fashion watches. I think your safe in picking out a surprise for her. But to always be safe, you could show her a few pics of maybe not your exact options but similar and see what style she likes. You already know she likes the Shinola, so staying close to that look would be safe (Or even just buying the Shinola;). If my husband gifted me any of the watches you have in mind, I’d be over the moon. Can’t think of a better way to encourage your spouse to be interested in your hobby than to buy them a cool watch too.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk