movements. Eta vs soprod vs st5
Like Tree7Likes

Thread: movements. Eta vs soprod vs st5

Page 1 of 2 1 2 LastLast
Results 1 to 10 of 14
  1. #1
    Member
    Join Date
    May 2014
    Location
    London, United Kingdom, United Kingdom
    Posts
    7

    movements. Eta vs soprod vs st5

    I'm interested in people's views on the different movements that Steinhart use, as for me is the heart and lungs of the watch and important to how I'd feel about the timepiece. For me a movement needs to be:
    1. Accurate (cosc is nice... But for my needs accurate just means 'enough for daily use')
    2. A bit 'blingy', by which I mean something to be proud of. As any engineer by training it is the intricacy and ingenuity of a mechanical movement that fascinates me.
    3. Easy to live with long term, so reliable and cheap and easy to get serviced.

    To my mind ETA movements score high enough (say 7/10) for 1 and 2, and their commonality means they score very high at 3.
    I'm unsure on the soprod and st5 movements. The st5 is basically an ETA clone isn't it? So I probably score it about equal but the soprod....? Maybe technically superior but not so common.... Longevity is unknown and what about servicing?

    What do others think is important and how do you view these movements?

  2. #2
    Member Up-n-coming's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2014
    Location
    FLORIDA USA
    Posts
    403

    Re: movements. Eta vs soprod vs st5

    I think your requsite #3 trumps all. ETA fits that bill. ETA can also be blinged up with gold wheels and blue screws. All my ETA's run within +/- 5 seconds a day. Get them (ETA's) while you still can.
    Neil Nevill and Chrome like this.

  3. #3
    Member
    Join Date
    Jan 2013
    Posts
    94

    Re: movements. Eta vs soprod vs st5

    I think it depends on the overall package as well - I picked up an auto nav b premium because of the sexy-ass display window for it's Soprod, whereas the ETA powered model has a solid case back.

    My 2 cents on the Soprod
    1. I've been pretty blown away so far... last 24hrs i've lost less than a second - the day before it was around 2 seconds
    2. I think it looks good - blued screws, nice decoration, the gold rotor helps
    3. Obviously I can't say much on this, but I've only heard good things
    Neil Nevill likes this.

  4. Remove Advertisements
    WatchUSeek.com
    Advertisements
     

  5. #4
    Member Farmfield's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2014
    Location
    Gothenburg - Sweden
    Posts
    92

    Re: movements. Eta vs soprod vs st5

    I think the 'Steinhart ST5' is actually made by ETA, so not a clone but a variant of the 2824-2, primarily differing in decoration. Though I can be dead wrong here.

    And here's the best comparison I found regarding the ETA and it's clones including some extreme close-ups on details.

    Comparison: Sea-Gull ST2130, ETA 2824-2, Peacock SL3000 | Watch Guy

    Quote Originally Posted by jamesnorrisuk View Post
    My 2 cents on the Soprod
    1. I've been pretty blown away so far... last 24hrs i've lost less than a second - the day before it was around 2 seconds
    Of my three automatics, my OVM with an ETA 2824-2 and my Parnis with a DG2813 chinese movement are both about as good in terms of keeping time, about +/-1 second a day (at most). My Orient Ray is about +/-5 seconds a day, often on the minus side.

    In a year I think my ETA will still be keeping good time, my Orient too, but the Parnis/DG2813 not so good.
    Though I can be dead wrong in this too... ;)
    Last edited by Farmfield; June 4th, 2014 at 19:03.
    Once upon a time, I was pretty f#¤%&/ awesome.

  6. #5
    Member
    Join Date
    May 2014
    Location
    London, United Kingdom, United Kingdom
    Posts
    7

    Re: movements. Eta vs soprod vs st5

    Quote Originally Posted by Up-n-coming View Post
    I think your requsite #3 trumps all. ETA fits that bill. ETA can also be blinged up with gold wheels and blue screws. All my ETA's run within +/- 5 seconds a day. Get them (ETA's) while you still can.
    I tend to agree. But I also agree with James. I love to see the movement. My OP has come about through helping a friend determine a 'proper watch' to buy as a present to himself and he too loves the sight of a movement. A display case back is a deal breaker/maker for him.
    So I'm trying to determine the benefits and risks of the soprod in particular.... The premium nav-b in 44mm looks very appealing. He also likes the Marine watches with the display case backs
    Up-n-coming likes this.

  7. #6
    Member
    Join Date
    Mar 2010
    Location
    Burnaby, BC
    Posts
    371

    Re: movements. Eta vs soprod vs st5

    Quote Originally Posted by Farmfield View Post
    I think the 'Steinhart ST5' is actually made by ETA, so not a clone but a variant of the 2824-2, primarily differing in decoration. Though I can be dead wrong here.
    You are dead wrong ;) The ST5 is a 2824-2 clone that uses parts sourced entirely from non-ETA suppliers in Switzerland. The whole point of it was to have an in-house replacement to deal with the dwindling availability of 2824-2's. Unlike the Soprod A10, the ST5 is the same dimension as the 2824-2 so it can be substituted into the existing line without having to redesign or modify the cases. The Soprod is a higher calibre than both the ST5 and 2824-2 with higher grade finishing, better shock protection and enhanced regulation; hence the reason it's being used in the premium line.
    Neil Nevill likes this.

  8. #7
    Member MrDagon007's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2012
    Location
    Hong Kong
    Posts
    5,256

    Re: movements. Eta vs soprod vs st5

    I mentioned the following before regarding the Soprod: it is almost certainly based on the Seiko 4L25 movement. It is not clear whether Soprod assembles it, or makes it itself based on the design, or receives ebauches from Seiko (the company did not return emails to a curious watchmaker). If you google you'll find pictures that demonstrate that the movements look identical, and associated discussions.
    In practice, the interesting thing is that this relatively rare Seiko movement was used in a few Credor watches - Seiko's luxury brand, positioned next to and above Grand Seiko. Knowing the company's attention to detail, this means that it is likely a very, very good movement that you can trust to give many years of great performance.
    Unless of course that you don't like the Japanese influence and rather prefer an all-Swiss movement. I consider Seiko's involvement as a quality. I would not hesitate buying a Seikoprod-powered watch.
    Neil Nevill likes this.

  9. #8
    Member
    Join Date
    Mar 2010
    Location
    Burnaby, BC
    Posts
    371

    Re: movements. Eta vs soprod vs st5

    Quote Originally Posted by Neil Nevill View Post
    So I'm trying to determine the benefits and risks of the soprod in particular.... The premium nav-b in 44mm looks very appealing. He also likes the Marine watches with the display case backs
    The benefits are you're getting a movement designed to compete against the higher calibre ETA 2892-2 which has a very good track record so far and keeps excellent time. The risk is that it's a relatively new movement that was a new design from the ground up so getting service at your local jeweller/watchmaker might be a little harder for the very common ETA 2824-2.

  10. #9
    Member Michael81's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2014
    Location
    Finland
    Posts
    421

    Re: movements. Eta vs soprod vs st5

    So far I am not especially impressed with the ST-5. My O1V is running around 15 seconds slow. That said, I have a Speedmaster Automatic, which has a Valjoux 7750, and that is also around 15 seconds slow (possibly more), but it dates back to the late 90s and needs a service. The 2824-2 was quite reliable in my Debaufre Ocean 1... until it wasn't. Had it serviced but it still runs consistently slow. I wish my watches would run fast instead, but no matter what position I leave them in overnight they still run slow.

    I'm (theoretically) taking delivery of a Stowa Flieger within the next week or so. That has the Top 2824-2 ebauche, so I'm curious to see how it performs.

  11. #10
    Member MrDagon007's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2012
    Location
    Hong Kong
    Posts
    5,256

    Re: movements. Eta vs soprod vs st5

    Quote Originally Posted by mithrilG60 View Post
    The benefits are you're getting a movement designed to compete against the higher calibre ETA 2892-2 which has a very good track record so far and keeps excellent time. The risk is that it's a relatively new movement that was a new design from the ground up so getting service at your local jeweller/watchmaker might be a little harder for the very common ETA 2824-2.

    Referring to what I wrote in my post just above yours, I suspect that "from the ground up" is not true at all
    It is true that it can be a drop in replacement for the 2892.

    Again, I have no problem with the likely design source being Seiko. In fact I just ordered the superlume new Pilot with Soprod.

    Borrowed pictures:
    Soprod:
    Name:  1390390d1392828033-who-makes-your-micro-image.jpg
Views: 2574
Size:  147.8 KB

    Seiko/Credor:
    Name:  img58007873.jpg
Views: 2626
Size:  131.4 KB

    In short, the Soprod is anything but "from the ground up", yet I expect it to be very good nevertheless.
    Last edited by MrDagon007; June 4th, 2014 at 20:50.
    Neil Nevill likes this.

Page 1 of 2 1 2 LastLast

Thread Information

Users Browsing this Thread

There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)

    Posting Permissions

    • You may not post new threads
    • You may not post replies
    • You may not post attachments
    • You may not edit your posts
    •