the two watches I'm replacing are both Seiko and both well-used. A skx007 that's over 15 years old and doesn't keep time very well despite multiple efforts to adjust, and a ska371 kinetic (wearing it winds like an automatic but powers a capacitor, so it is really a quartz watch) that's about 12 years old. I just replaced the capacitor on that one, but thinking it's time for a new watch. I wore the 007 mostly with Zulu straps. I recently tried a relatively low-cost substitute, a Deep Blue master diver 1000. It's a nice, chunky watch that I am sure I will wear on hikes and on the water, but the rubber strap doesn't help it bridge to wearing with nicer clothes, nor does the thicker case. and, for whatever it's worth, I read some less-than-flattering things about the quality of Deep Blue's metal bracelets, and they are kind of ridiculously overpriced anyway.
I am considering my options and willing to spend a little money. I have a few Citizen eco-drive watches, including the ugly but super-reliable ecozilla, but I'm looking for something that's automatic and that can double as a decent-looking watch. I'm not a diver, but I will wear this in the water when I'm swimming, canoeing, sailing, snorkeling. because I'm replacing two wear-to-wind watches, I'm looking primarily at automatics. I also have a large enough wrist that the ecozilla looks fine, so I'm thinking something in the 43-46mm range for a case. Finally, like the previous watches, this will be a buy and wear it out proposition, but considering I'm willing to spend some more money, I'll get the watch serviced more often than the Seiko watches I'm retiring.
here is what I'm looking at:
-the new-ish Seiko sumo - 3d generation, with the sapphire glass.
-Certina DS action diver with a metal band.
-Longines HydroConquest - larger size, so in the 43-44mm range.
-I peeped Hamilton's frogman line, gorgeous watches, but leaning away. the black bezel version is kind of small for my wrist, and the big titanium one seems too thick, too red (bezel insert), and too informal for what I want.
-Steinhart Ocean 44.
-Tissot Sea Star 1000.
Except for Seiko, whose pricing has gone up a lot as they build a rep as a more upscale brand, I have never worn a watch from any of these places. I recognize that five of these are Swiss watches, four of which are Swatch-owned companies, and they all have effectively the same ETA movement. Still, I welcome opinions about the various brands I named in the Swatch portfolio.
Also, Seiko replaced the old Sumo movement with caliber 6R35, and I'm wondering about reliability & accuracy. I'm fine with a watch that gains or loses a minute every couple of days, that's part of owning an automatic in my experience, more curious whether Seiko rolling out a new movement has generated any buzz, pro or con, other than the new movement's greater storage capacity that brings it closer to the ETA.
thanks for sharing opinions.